Quantcast Index
College Media Network
  • Home
  • General Info

Letter to the Editor: Athletics should receive budget cuts

Abstract:
...

  • Displaying 1 - 8 of 8

A. William Steinbeck

posted 11/19/09 @ 7:18 AM CST

I am very glad to see that someone else is willing to prioritize academics at one of the smartest schools in Missouri, a university which touts itself as the Harvard of the Midwest, over athletics. While I agree with the argument that physical training ought to be a part of education, and significantly at that, organized sports are an accessory to physical training. We can have physical education and health classes in a full spectrum of athletic areas without necessarily having a full competitive program in these areas.

I will not take the perspective that all sports should be cut. However, if cuts need to be made, my department (Music) has already suffered in the quality of education it can provide because of decreased funding, even through a steady increase in Music majors. Let's even the playing field by eliminating one sport, maybe two, proportionately affecting all departments similarly and preserving the scholastic nature of every department at this university. If it means still having a team but not offering as many scholarships, that may be done. If the luxury of having a less-supported sport must go, times are rough. The sport can continue as an extracurricular organization without direct support from the University. While I'm not saying Bulldog Football is out, Daniel mentioned there are tough choices to be made, and the University must see which choices will and will not hurt the academic reputation that brought me and many of my fellow students to Truman.

Jonny Athlete

posted 11/19/09 @ 9:57 AM CST

Cuts to the athletic department are something that has to be considered along with other things at the university in times of financial difficulty, but realize how many students are brought to the university by the various athletic programs that are offered. Without athletics, Truman would be put at a major disadvantage versus competing schools for students. No athletics translates to a much lower enrollment for the university and less money. You also clearly have no idea what amounts of money some athletes receive. Very few at this level are on full scholarship. Do some research next time smart guy.

Dan Heagney

posted 11/19/09 @ 3:01 PM CST

You missed the point smart guy :P I recognize that a full cut of athletics would not happen, nor do I expect it to. I just wanted people to start thinking about other venues to save money aside from cutting out professors. Athletics should receive disproportionately more cuts then academics, because we are here FOR and BECAUSE of academics. I just want people to start thinking about what is considered the "foundation" of a university.

Originally posted by

Jonny Athlete

Cuts to the athletic department are something that has to be considered along with other things at the university in times of financial difficulty, but realize how many students are brought to the university by the various athletic programs that are offered. Without athletics, Truman would be put at a major disadvantage versus competing schools for students. No athletics translates to a much lower enrollment for the university and less money. You also clearly have no idea what amounts of money some athletes receive. Very few at this level are on full scholarship. Do some research next time smart guy.

Very upset

posted 11/19/09 @ 9:34 PM CST

Mr. Heagney,

What would you propose for the students who directly use athletics as hands-on experience for their major? For example, athletic training students spend all their time with sports teams and greatly benefit from this experience. What about exercise science majors who use athletic teams for research? What about sport psychology patterns that require some sport in order to allow any research? This doesn't even begin to cover the fact of the school's image. Believe it or not, some students don't want to go to a ridiculously augmented academic institution. Recruitment of high quality students would suffer if athletics received any more cuts. Period. Athletics already receives the blame for every other university problem; give them a break. Yes, I agree that academics are vital and should be the main priority of an institution. However, being a well-rounded school is even more important.

It's a shame that students like you can't get out from behind the books and enjoy athletics.

OhEye

posted 11/20/09 @ 11:10 AM CST

Following up on this comment as well, I wonder if Mr. Heagney actually did think about some of the other academic ramifications should the athletics department see major cuts to the point of elimination.

With more than 400+ student-athletes, not only is there the potential for upwards of 7-8% of the student population to transfer to another school (after all, these students have gifts of being athletic, so they will use them somewhere else while receiving an education .. just like someone who is incredibly good at writing might do should the Index, for example, get cut), but as a result, many academic disciplines would suffer - reducing the number of faculty and staff members that would be able to be retained.

I believe there are a LOT of student-athletes who are HES majors ... say if there were suddenly 120 (I'm just guessing on this number, but to me it seems at least semi-accurate) fewer HES majors due to athletics cut + transfering students, I would have to think that a handful of those faculty members would be out of work thanks to a lower number of students enrolled in classes.

And finally, how about all of the athletics staff members who would be out of a job? I'm not just talking about administration either, but how about coaches (many of which also teach - I'm not sure if you were aware), athletic trainers (again, many of which teach), and custodians too.

I understand what you were probably trying to do in trying to point out the fact that this is an academic instition and, in your mind, athletics don't play a role at all in that. However, underneath the surface and with a bit more logic, it's clear to see that they do - just like many other extra-curricular areas on campus.

Perhaps the answer DOES lie in an earlier comment about cutting one or two sports, similar to what some other departments are facing? Now that would be much more logical than the original letter...

Originally posted by

Very upset

Mr. Heagney,

What would you propose for the students who directly use athletics as hands-on experience for their major? For example, athletic training students spend all their time with sports teams and greatly benefit from this experience. What about exercise science majors who use athletic teams for research? What about sport psychology patterns that require some sport in order to allow any research? This doesn't even begin to cover the fact of the school's image. Believe it or not, some students don't want to go to a ridiculously augmented academic institution. Recruitment of high quality students would suffer if athletics received any more cuts. Period. Athletics already receives the blame for every other university problem; give them a break. Yes, I agree that academics are vital and should be the main priority of an institution. However, being a well-rounded school is even more important.

It's a shame that students like you can't get out from behind the books and enjoy athletics.

Devil's Advocate

posted 11/23/09 @ 3:01 PM CST

I believe the point is that cuts need to be uniform; if one area of the school will see cut backs so should the others with respect to student interest. Truman has more varsity sports teams than most schools in the region. And I regret to say we may be a jack of trades but a master of only a few. Although this fits well with our liberal arts mission, again transforming some of these teams into localized unofficial teams would alleviate some financial stress.

And before you belly ache and moan about student dissatisfaction why don't you talk with a theater student. Those poor guys just lost a third of their staff.

Well Rounded

posted 12/03/09 @ 5:32 PM CST

I am a former member of Truman's women's swim team and I found your letter especially derisive. Several sports at Truman barely receive enough funding to support a single full ride scholarship, much less new gear, equipment, or facilities. Yet these sports still cultivate some of the most dedicated and talented students that don't get paid to play. So please don't consider us all single-minded jocks.
We balance competition with academics and extracurriculars in ways that make us valuable in the job market, and even more so with Truman's name behind us. I am not in any way trying to undermine others' activities or hobbies, but truthfully there is little else that compares to the athletic experience in terms of hard work and personal goal-setting. So please don't think that throwing Truman's athletics under the bus is going to improve or even maintain the status quo of quality student experiences in troubled times. You're really throwing away a proud, albeit small, tradition of champions that fought for Truman's namesake, not to mention a boatload of alumni contributions...

Chris

posted 12/06/09 @ 3:00 PM CST

Truman is one of the top producers of Academic All-Americans. Female atheletes have the highest cumulative GPA on campus. Cutting athletics would result in a significant loss in students.

Something that current students need to understand is that there are different budgets for different areas on campus. Yes, we could cut some of the athletic programs, but the money isn't going to go towards academics. It's going to go towards other athletic programs.
  • Displaying 1 - 8 of 8

Post Your Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

Poll

Will Troy Paino make an effective University President?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement